Inquiry finds widespread misconduct in women’s pro soccer
ANNE M. PETERSON AP Sports Writer
Posted:
Updated:
An investigation commissioned by the National Women’s Soccer League and its players union found “widespread misconduct” directed at players dating back to the beginnings nearly a decade ago of the league.
A report detailing the results of the year-long investigation was published Wednesday, a little over two months after the release in October of a report on a separate investigation by former acting U.S. Attorney General Sally Q. Yates that found emotional abuse and sexual misconduct were systemic in the sport, impacting multiple teams, coaches and players.
The second investigation also found instances of sexual abuse and manipulation. The NWSL-commissioned report said club staff in positions of power “made inappropriate sexual remarks to players, mocked players’ bodies, pressured players to lose unhealthy amounts of weight, crossed professional boundaries with players and created manipulative working conditions.”
“They used derogatory and insulting language towards players, displayed insensitivity toward players’ mental health, and engaged in retaliation against players who attempted to report or did report concerns,” the report said.
“This report clearly reflects how our league systemically failed to protect our players. On behalf of the Board and the league, let me first and foremost sincerely apologize to our players for those failures and missteps. They deserve, at a minimum, a safe and secure environment to participate at the highest level in a sport they love, and they have my unwavering commitment that delivering that change will remain a priority each and every day,” NWSL Commissioner Jessica Berman said in a news release.
Riley, who has denied the allegations, was fired by the North Carolina Courage in the aftermath. He was among five head coaches in the league who were either fired or resigned in 2021 amid claims of misconduct.
The fallout has continued into this year. Portland Thorns owner Merritt Paulson announced on Dec. 1 that he was putting the team up for sale amid calls for him to do so that began after the Yates report detailed how the Thorns mishandled complaints about Riley when he coached the team in 2014-15. Paulson stepped down from a decision-making role with the team in October and two Thorns executives were fired.
The investigative team for the joint investigation reached out to 780 current and former players, all 12 NWSL teams and 90 current and former club staff, and those from the league office. More than 200 documents were reviewed during the probe, which was conducted by the law firms of Covington & Burling and Weil, Gotshal & Manges.
“This report speaks to the power of the players, the power of the truth and the power of a strong labor union,” Meghann Burke, executive director of the NWSL Players Association, said during a video conference that also included Berman. “Players have willed this moment into existence. The NWSL Players Association would like to thank, honor and acknowledge every player, whether known or unknown, identified or not, in this report, for speaking truth to power. Players who have lent their names to this report know that kind of courage is hard to understand.”
Two coaches, James Clarkson of the Houston Dash and Amanda Cromwell of the Orlando Pride, were suspended earlier this year at the recommendation of investigators. Cromwell was subsequently fired.
Like the Yates report commissioned by U.S. Soccer, the new report largely focused on alleged misconduct involving Riley, former Chicago Red Stars coach Rory Dames and former Racing Louisville coach Christy Holly. The three were among those who were fired or resigned last year.
It also detailed allegations against former OL Reign coach Farid Benstiti, former Washington Spirit coach Richie Burke and former Gotham general manager Alyse LaHue, among others. Benstiti, Burke and LaHue were also let go or stepped down in 2021.
The report said an ingrained culture contributed to players’ unwillingness to come forward, including fears about the instability of the league and job security, the expectation of gratitude and acquiescence, sexism and gender bias, and a lack of confidence in the league’s response.
“The individual incidents and recurrent practices detailed in this report reflect the experiences of players, not only in isolated moments but also more broadly, as women playing soccer in a league historically owned and run by men,” it said.
Contributing factors included a lack of background checks or similar vetting for coaches, no clear direction from the league front office for handling misconduct allegations, and insufficient staff at both the club and league level for addressing complaints.
The investigation offered recommendations to “ensure that players and staff within the league and its clubs feel safe and confident in reporting misconduct.”
They included revising the league antiharassment policy to more clearly define retaliation, addressing racist and derogatory language, including the non-fraternization policy and requiring clubs to revise their antiharassment policies to be consistent with the league’s policy.
The report also calls for guidelines addressing appropriate interactions between players and club staff, including a responsible drinking policy; to establish guidelines addressing appropriate locations for one-on-one meetings between team staff and players; consider establishing guidelines regarding socializing between players; provide written guidance to coaches and other team staff stating it’s inappropriate to make degrading comments or jokes about a player’s weight; and require coaches to adhere to club medical staffs’ decisions regarding player health and ability to train and play.
Berman said officials need time to analyze the report but she expects meaningful reforms will be in place for next season.
STR
FILE - Brazil's Pele, center, is hoisted on the shoulders of his teammates after Brazil won the World Cup soccer final against Italy, 4-1, in Mexico City's Estadio Azteca, Mexico. Brazil's third World Cup triumph meant it kept the Jules Rimet trophy for good. The Hand of God. Zidane's headbutt. Gazza's tears. Many of soccer's most iconic moments have taken place at the World Cup, the latest edition of which starts in Qatar on Sunday. The Associated Press has covered the tournament through the years and followed the world's greatest players, none more so than Diego Maradona and Pelé.(AP Photo, file)
STR
FILE - An aerial view of the Centenario stadium in Montevideo, Uruguay, July 30, 1930 during the World Cup final soccer match in which Uruguay defeated Argentina 4-2. (AP Photo/File)
AP
FILE - Uruguay's first goal in the World Cup final soccer match against Argentina, in Montevideo, Uruguay on July 30, 1930. Uruguay defeated Argentina by four goals to two. (AP Photo/File)
STR
FILE - The Italian soccer team perform the fascist salute in Colombes Stadium, Paris, before the start of the World Cup final soccer match against Hungary on June 19, 1938. Earlier in the tournament that was taking place amid the drumbeat of war, the team caused consternation by wearing black shirts in a match. (AP Photo/File)
STR
FILE - U.S. center forward Joe Gaetjens is carried off by cheering fans after his team beat England 1-0 in a World Cup soccer match in Belo Horizonte, Brazil on June 28, 1950. (AP Photo/File)
Anonymous
FILE - Uruguay player Ghiggia scores during the World Cup final soccer match against Brazil, in the Maracana Stadium in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil on July 16, 1950. Uruguay won 2-1. (AP Photo/File)
STR
FILE - West Germany's Helmut Rahn, center with arms raised, celebrates after equalizing in the World Cup final soccer match against Hungary, at Wankdorf Stadium, in Bern, Switzerland on July 4, 1954. (AP Photo/File)
STR
FILE - Brazil's 17-year-old Pele, left, weeps on the shoulder of goalkeeper Gilmar Dos Santos Neves, after Brazil's 5-2 victory over Sweden in the World Cup final soccer match, in Stockholm, Sweden on June 29, 1958. (AP Photo/File)
STR
FILE - Italian forward Giorgio Ferrini, centre, is sent off by British referee Ken Aston after an incident during the first half of the World Cup soccer match against Chile in Santiago on June 2, 1962. Ferrini refused to leave the field and was removed by police officers. The match has been labelled the 'Battle of Santiago'. (AP Photo/File)
Rider-Rider
FILE - Detective Chief Inspector William Little, left, holds the World Cup, as Senior Commander John Lawlor, centre, and Chief Superintendent William Gilbert, admire the cup after its safe return to the police at Cannon Row Police Station, (Scotland Yard), London on March 28, 1966. The cup was returned to the police after it was found in the garden of David Corbett's home in Beulah Hill, Norwood, London, United Kingdom, by his mongrel dog "Pickles" who sniffed it out while being taken for a walk. (AP Photo/Rider-Rider, File)
AP
FILE - The North Korean soccer team line-up before their match against Portugal, at Goodison Park, Liverpool, England, on July 23, 1966. Portugal defeated North Korea 5-3. (AP Photo, File)
STR
FILE - A shot from England's Geoff Hurst, not in photo, bounces down from the West Germany crossbar during the World Cup final at London's Wembley Stadium on July 30, 1966. The linesman gave it as a goal and England went to to win 4-2. (AP Photo/File)
STF
FILE - The teams from West Germany, in white shirts, and East Germany line up for the national anthems before the start of the World Cup Group 1 soccer match in Hamburg, on June 22, 1974. The match ended in a 1-0 win for East Germany. (AP Photo, File)
STR
FILE - West Germany captain, Franz Beckenbauer holds up the World Cup trophy after his team defeated the Netherlands 2-1, in the World Cup final soccer match at Munich's Olympic stadium, in West Germany on July 7, 1974. (AP Photo/File)
STF
FILE - Mario Kempes of Argentina, right, celebrates, after scoring Argentina's second goal against the Netherlands, during their World Cup final soccer match, at the River Plate Stadium, in Buenos Aires, Argentina on Sunday, June 25, 1978. It was Argentina's first World Cup triumph. (AP Photo/File)
STR
FILE - Algerian soccer supporters show money to photographers in protest, in Gijon, Spain, after the World Cup soccer match between West Germany and Austria on June 25, 1982. West Germany were leading Austria 1-0 after 10 minutes of play, then both teams pointlessly kicked the ball around, barely breaking a sweat and ensuring they both qualified at Algeria's expense. (AP Photo/File)
Gianni Foggia
FILE - Captain Carlos Alberto, center, of Brazil, holds the gold Jules Rimet trophy after his team defeated Italy in the World Cup final soccer match at Azteca Stadium, in Mexico City, June 21, 1970. Brazil won, 4-1. (AP Photo/Gianni Foggia, File)
STR
FILE - Italy's Paolo Rossi celebrates, after scoring the second goal for his team during their World Cup match second round soccer match against Brazil, in Barcelona, Spain on July 5, 1982. Italy, who beat Brazil 3-2 in a classic match, went on to win the tournament with Rossi scoring six goals. (AP Photo/File)
AP
FILE - Italy's Marco Tardelli, right, hits the ball past West German defender Bernd Forster, to score his team's second goal, during the World Cup Final in the Santiago Bernabau Stadium, Madrid,on July 11, 1982. Italy defeated West Germany 3-1. (AP Photo, File)
SUB
FILE - Argentina's Diego Maradona, left, beats England goalkeeper Peter Shilton to a high ball and scores his first of two goals in a World Cup quarterfinal soccer match, in Mexico City on June 22, 1986. This goal has gone down as the "Hand of God" as Maradona used his left fist to knock a ball past England's Shilton. (El Grafico, Buenos Aires via AP/File)
STR
FILE - Argentina's Diego Maradona, second left, is about to score his second goal against England, during their World Cup quarter final soccer match, in Mexico City, Mexico on June 22, 1986. England's Terry Butcher, left, tries to tackle Maradona, while England's goalkeeper Peter Shilton is on the ground. Argentina won the match 2-1. (AP Photo/File)
Carlo Fumagalli
FILE - Diego Maradona, holds up the trophy, after Argentina beat West Germany 3-2 in the World Cup soccer final match, at the Atzeca Stadium, in Mexico City on June 29, 1986. (AP Photo/Carlo Fumagalli, File)
Dieter Endlicher
FILE - Dejected Argentine players Nestor Gabriel Lorenzo, left, and Jorge Luis Burruchaga walk off the pitch, past unidentified celebrating Cameroon players, after the opening match of the soccer World Cup, in Milan, Italy on June 8, 1990. The World Cup has produced its fair share of shocks, not least when Cameroon defeated defending champion Argentina 1-0 in 1990. (AP Photo/File)
Roberto Pfeil
FILE - England's Paul Gascoigne cries as he is escorted off the field by team captain Terry Butcher, after England lost a penalty shoot-out in the World Cup semifinal soccer match against West Germany in Turin, Italy on July 4, 1990. (AP Photo/Roberto Pfeil, File)
Eric Draper
FILE - Colombia's Andres Escobar, lies on the ground during a World Cup soccer match against the United States in the Rose Bowl, Pasadena on June 22, 1994. The US defeated Colombia by 2-1, with Escobar scoring an own-goal. Just a few days later, Escobar was shot dead in his home town of Medellin. (AP Photo/Eric Draper, File)
Luca Bruno
FILE - Roberto Baggio of Italy looks disappointed after Brazilian goalkeeper Taffarel saved his penalty shot, during the World Cup Final, in Pasadena, Ca., USA, on July 17, 1994. Brazil defeated Italy 3-2 on penalties in the final to win the World Cup. (AP Photo/Luca Bruno, File)
Michel Euler
FILE - French striker Zinedine Zidane holds up the World Cup trophy after France defeated Brazil 3-0 during the final of the soccer World Cup 98 at the Stade de France in Paris on Sunday, July 12, 1998. (AP Photo/Michel Euler, File)
Dusan Vranic
FILE - Brazil's Ronaldo celebrates scoring against Germany during the World Cup final soccer match at the Yokohama stadium in Yokohama, Japan on June 30, 2002. Brazil won the match 2-0 with Ronaldo scoring both goals. . (AP Photo/Dusan Vranic, File)
Jasper Juinen
FILE - France's Zinedine Zidane, left, looks on as Italy's Marco Materazzi lies injured, and Italy's Fabio Cannavaro reacts, during extra time in the World Cup final soccer match between Italy and France, at the Olympic Stadium, in Berlin on July 9, 2006. Zidane was sent off minutes before the end of the final after head-butting Italy defender Materazzi. (AP Photo/Jasper Juinen, File)
Martin Meissner
FILE - Spain's Andres Iniesta celebrates after scoring the only goal in the World Cup final soccer match against the Netherlands at Soccer City in Johannesburg, South Africa on July 11, 2010. (AP Photo/Martin Meissner, File)
Ricardo Mazalan
FILE - Uruguay's Luis Suarez holds his teeth after colliding with Italy's Giorgio Chiellini's shoulder during the group D World Cup soccer match between Italy and Uruguay at the Arena das Dunas in Natal, Brazil on June 24, 2014. (AP Photo/Ricardo Mazalan, File)
Natacha Pisarenko
FILE - Brazil's Fernandinho reacts after Germany's Toni Kroos during scored his side's third goal during the World Cup semifinal soccer match between Brazil and Germany at the Mineirao Stadium in Belo Horizonte, Brazil, Tuesday, July 8, 2014. Germany won the match 7-1. (AP Photo/Natacha Pisarenko, File)
Natacha Pisarenko
FILE - Germany's Mario Goetze scores his side's first goal in extra time against Argentina's goalkeeper Sergio Romero during the World Cup final soccer match at the Maracana Stadium in Rio de Janeiro, Brazil, Sunday, July 13, 2014. (AP Photo/Natacha Pisarenko, File)
Natacha Pisarenko
FILE - From left to right, FIFA President Gianni Infantino, Russia's President Vladimir Putin, France's President Emmanuel Macron and Croatia's President Kolinda Grabar-Kitarovic stand under the pouring rain during the awards ceremony after final match between France and Croatia at the 2018 soccer World Cup in the Luzhniki Stadium in Moscow, Russia, Sunday, July 15, 2018. (AP Photo/Natacha Pisarenko, File)
Steve Dipaola
FILE - Portland Thorns fans hold signs during the first half of the team's National Women's Soccer League soccer match against the Houston Dash in Portland, Ore., Oct. 6, 2021. An investigation commissioned by the NWSL and its players union found “widespread misconduct" directed at players dating back to the beginnings nearly a decade ago of the country's top women's professional league. (AP Photo/Steve Dipaola, File)
